Required reviews completed taylor and francis It's a publishing conglomerate. The editorial standards of each journal are up to that journal's editors. The manuscript status shows reviews complete and the manuscript is with the editor since Sep 3, 2025 · At this point the status of your article will change to 'Completed' and no further modifications can be made in Editorial Manager. By: Alison McGonagle-O’Connell, Marketing Manager, Aries Systems Corporation Once you’ve submitted a manuscript for publication in a journal, you may be anxious about your manuscript status. Our ‘Excellence in Peer Review: Taylor & Francis Reviewer Training Network’ supports researchers in becoming more effective peer reviewers. Jun 10, 2025 · Guide to Submitting Your Paper to Taylor & Francis Submitting your paper to Taylor & Francis can be a straightforward process if you follow their guidelines and procedures. Required reviews complete - Some or all assigned reviewers have completed their reviews. Only invite the number of reviewers that you need and change the number of required reports as needed – the article will then appear in the correct list when the reports are returned. The associate editor (AE) will now make a first decision on the manuscript and share this with you shortly. I checked the link again after 3 days and I noticed that the date has changed to 19th of April (check the attached image) with the same status of "Review Complete". We work to establish and sustain peer review integrity on every journal. Decision in Process This means that the editor is now taking a decision on your paper based on the peer reviewer comments and his/her own opinion. g. Once your article is published, it can be found on Taylor & Francis Online, and you can start to promote it and build your research impact. Review invitations sent: 2+ Checking the submission status from the journal editorial system also showed "Required Reviews Completed" with the same date of 16th of April. For some journals, the status may include the decision term e. T&F isn't a journal. It's five months already after the reviews were completed. Rachael joined Taylor & Francis five years ago and until March ran the implementation programme for the online submission and peer review systems, ScholarOne Manuscripts and Aries Editorial Manager. I see the article is open access, which We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. To learn more about how we support accessibility, view our Accessible Content Guidelines. Some are highly reputable, others less so. A 2015 Taylor & Francis study found that most researchers, across all subject areas, rated the contribution of peer review towards improving their article as 8 or above out of 10. It also provides you with a step-by-step guide to writing a peer review and training to hone your skills. Jan 31, 2024 · Taylor and Francis reviewer guidelines request that ‘Reviewers should provide a constructive, comprehensive, evidenced, and appropriately substantial peer review report’, and the vast majority of reviews that I see tick all these boxes and more. After submitting your review report In this FAQs section, you’ll find answers to the most common questions you may have after reviewing for a Taylor & Francis journal. It publishes probably thousands of journals in many different fields. We have written to the editor over four times but the responses from them seem to persuade Peer review is also a very useful source of feedback for authors, allowing them to receive constructive support to advance their work. 'Completed - Accept'. To begin, it is important to carefully review the specific requirements for the journal you wish to submit to. Editorial Process Understanding peer review Every article published in a Taylor & Francis journal goes through rigorous peer review. Journals usually ask reviewers to complete their reviews within 3-4 weeks. Dec 4, 2024 · indicates that the reviews were very quick and prompt with the review process completed on 19th January, 2024. However, since then we have not heard from the editorial board yet on the decision. Here are some guidelines to help you progress from an author or researcher to a peer reviewer. At Taylor & Francis, we understand the importance of an efective peer review when authors choose to submit their research. Jul 20, 2025 · Search and explore the millions of quality, peer-reviewed journal articles published under the Taylor & Francis, Routledge and Dove Medical Press imprints. Make it clear to the reviewer that it is a re-review and that they have seen the article before. The review process varies from journal to journal, but this guide gives On behalf of Taylor & Francis and the Editors, we thank you for donating your time and expertise to the peer review process. ” 7. A Taylor & Francis study supports this, finding that most researchers, across all subject areas, rated the contribution of peer review towards improving their article as 8 or above out of 10. Generally, Elsevier journals provide decisions within 1 or 2 weeks, however, the publisher like Taylor and Francis, and springer take 2-4 weeks to provide a final decision. With 28 peer-reviewed journals, the Expert Collection is the world’s largest series of review journals in clinical medicine and R&D. I submitted a manuscript in the year beginning of the year 2022 to a reputed journal by Taylor and Francis. Read more about format-free submission and how to find out if it’s available for your chosen journal. Simply browse or search for content. The online portal indicates that the reviews were very quick and prompt with the review process completed on 19th Improving journal instructions for authors At Taylor & Francis, we are enhancing this crucial step of the publication journey to be author-centric, meeting the needs of researchers to get this information quickly when they are at the ‘I want to submit my research paper, tell me how’ stage. Sep 12, 2021 · The paper I published recently was submitted through ScholarOne system, and based on my experience, after the review before editor's decision, the status remains under review. Over 350 Taylor & Francis journals now accept manuscript submissions without any specific formatting requirements, saving you time and worry. Reviews Completed means that the peer review of the manuscript is complete. How long does peer review take? A question often asked by authors, but also important to editors, is how long does it take between submission and publication of an article. You will receive more information via email from the production team regarding the publication process. Recently, I learnt that the submission can also be done through the Taylor & Francis website, and there when the paper returns from review it shows decision pending (waiting for editorial decision), while in the Scholar Do you know the requirements for your target journal? Visit Taylor & Francis Online to check the specific submission requirements for your chosen journal. Aug 17, 2022 · Usually, the time frame is clear in all correspondence to reviewers invited to review submissions taking the 3 – 5 weeks option, and they accept the invitation on this basis in Taylor & Francis Jun 21, 2024 · Is the “Under review” status on Tailor and Francis the equivalent of “with editor” on Elsevier, or is the meaning in the peer review process? I have a paper with this status on taylor and Read our best practice guidelines for peer review, along with some answered questions to support editors and journals. Guide to submission status indicatorsUpdated 22 June 2023 Your complete guide to submitting your research paper and navigating the peer review process Guidance, developments, news, and ideas for Taylor & Francis authors Jul 7, 2020 · Understanding customized editorial statuses can help authors understand which stage a submission is at within the peer-review process. However, the short period of time since submission seems to suggest that this is a rapid publication journal or that the peer review was done internally (in case the journal had the Our Pre-Submission Expert Review refines clarity, structure & fit to rapidly increase your acceptance prospects. Decision in process - The handling editor has entered a decision but the decision is not yet finalized and has not been sent to the authors. Jul 14, 2024 · I submitted a paper to one of Taylor and Francis journal on the 6th December, 2023. So it's generally a reputable publisher but there can still be individual journals that don't do proper peer review. After peer review (which may require you to complete some revisions), your article will hopefully be accepted and enter the production process. '. ۵- اتمام فرآیند داوری (Required Reviews Complete): این حالت یا پیام نشان می‌دهد که همه داروان فرآنید داوری مقاله را به اتمام رسانده‌اند و مقاله بعد از داوری داوران، به دست ادیتور مجله رسیده است. Nov 18, 2020 · Answer: This is quite simple. In the meantime, enjoy your complimentary 30 days’ free access to journals on Taylor & Francis Online. Oct 14, 2014 · So, do not be surprised if this happens: once the additional review is completed, the status will come back to “Required Reviews Complete. Under review - The handling editor has begun to invite peer reviewers to evaluate the submission. In this FAQs section, you’ll find answers to the most common questions you may have during the review of a Taylor & Francis journal. Uncover factors influencing review duration and decode transitions from 'Required Review Completed' to 'Under Review. A vital part of this means ensuring that reviewers have the right resources to carry out their work eficiently and efectively. Get expert feedback before submission with Taylor & Francis. Taylor & Francis is committed to supplying accessible materials to ensure that as many readers as possible can engage with the work we publish. You may be asking: Who sees the manuscript after I submit it? When Oct 21, 2020 · Democritus University of Thrace Most of Taylor and Francis journals websites mention the review time (as well as other times such as time for first review etc) at the "Journal metrics" tab. This is a hard question to answer, but often peer review is the lengthiest part of this process. This provides reviewers with resources to assist in the creation of quality reviews. In this FAQs section, you’ll find answers to the most common questions you may have before reviewing for a Taylor & Francis journal. Many of our journals now give peer reviewers 30-days’ free access to Taylor & Francis journal content upon agreeing to review. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. We hope that you will be happy to review further manuscripts for us in the future. Dive into the dynamics of manuscript status changes in peer review. k8bb lywg w914thqe 2mxxdyg mdjcr fdyo 8u 39x t1o9h hgdhh