Is diy co2 worth it Aug 29, 2024 · Building a CO2 laser cutter from scratch can be a rewarding and fulfilling experience for DIY enthusiasts. Compressed CO2 tanks are easy to control but costly and require regular refills. 00 advertised as Aquarium CO2 pressurized systems. Are those diy co2 kits from amazon worth it for nano planted tanks? I have a 10 gallon and don’t want to go all out on pressurized co2 system yet until I get a little experience with co2 first. Now they are selling these new DIY kits that use citric acid and soda and even come with a solenoid valve> Apr 24, 2012 · Hi, I have had a couple of email requests for information on my do-it-yourself CO2 probe experience. And face it, once you figured out how to make a DIY bottle, the gas separator is not much more work. The added room in the cabinet may be an argument, but again, I'd make the Apr 23, 2013 · Is doing CO2 really worth it? I keep thinking about it after seeing it all over the forums. Was it worth it? Not really. DIY CO2 is pretty simple to do. Buy a needle valve to control the flow of co2 generated by the reaction. Should I use a DIY CO2 or pressurized CO2 system? We have tested many types of DIY systems using yeast, citric acid, and other mixtures, and while they may be cheaper, they are not as stable as a pressurized CO2 system using a regulator and cylinder. CO2 systems can vary greatly in price; budget systems can work without breaking the bank. Does it work? Mostly. A place for aquatic flora and fauna enthusiasts! Whether you have a question to ask or a planted tank… We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Trust me on this one—just buy a decent diffuser to save yourself the headache. I feel their DIY CO2 kit cater entry hobbyists trying to get an inkling of what pressurized CO2 can do for their plants but lack cost-efficiency and control for the long-term. In fact, I've seen some awesome nano-tanks with no filter, lights, fertz, CO2, etc. Dec 2, 2021 · I think they currently make the best in-tank CO2 diffusers, good aqua soil, and their outflow skimmer looks enticing. I would say that it's all in your plant selection, baseline water chemistry, tank location, and maintenance schedule. The sugar and yeast method is defiantly not worth trying, less the goal is to just have a little fun trying new things. Will I be throwing this out in a few days in exchange for an actual CO2 pump? Yeah probably. DIY), and alternatives like fertilizers and lighting adjustments. Even then, when you open the door the CO2 from your house/basement will fill into the grow space. DIY CO2. I don't see it being a bad buy for beginners at $22. For me now its not about acquiring the pressurised CO2 but adding more lights! My light level Yes it's worth it if your really interested in impressive plant growth but if you just want to make a comfortable environment for your fish it's not really worth it. Plants use CO2 and water to make the sugars they need for their growth, which can be made in a DIY generator. And the results are very beautiful planted tanks. It offers the advantages of cost savings, customization options, and valuable learning opportunities. A reliable pressurized system with a solenoid (trust me you want one) costs in excess of $200 at the low end. Adding enhanced CO2 levels to your grow room can significantly boost plant growth without altering the way you grow. Jan 26, 2017 · Also is there anything else in need to know about the reactor or some tips because if I'm going to go about doing diy CO2 I think having the rector is the only thing that will make the whole system work well and be worth it. I ran an inexpensive DIY CO2 system for a year and the results were night and day with some of the plants I was growing. Aug 11, 2015 · There's absolutely nothing wrong with a DIY co2 system. Plant growth accelerates as you increase CO2 levels up to around 1, 500 PPM, with growers observing up to a 100 increase in grow speed at 1, 500 PPM. :o First off, my interest and most of my original information came from Vaughn of Hoppy fame. The CO2 burner costs about $300 to $700 depending on output but you also require a CO2 sensor and controller which cost about $200 to $300. The marginal benefits of CO2 addition are not worth any effort in a tent. My tank is a 45 gallon. As a general rule, CO2 is never a bad idea for a planted tank. So I know this is not a completely fair comparison since I've rescaped but here's my experience with using Co2 for the last couple months. Jan 12, 2020 · Hello I need to purchase a CO2 pressurized system because I have more black beard algae in my tank that I can deal with right now. bottle. A good quality diffuser is inexpensive and crucial for efficiently dissolving CO2 into the water. FZONE Aquarium Co2 Regulator DC Solenoid with Big Dual Gauge Display and Apr 2, 2014 · I would steer clear of the DIY or other low end CO2 methods you mentioned. Sep 27, 2009 · I spent the past two years messing with DIY CO2, and honestly it is a gigantic pain. If size is an issue use a regulator designed for a paintball tank. If you've got any questions, drop th Apr 13, 2025 · In this guide, we’ll cover everything from CO₂ systems to DIY setups, and exactly how and when to use CO₂ in your grow. The interesting thing is that pearling activities are as normal as normal CO2 levels. It's currently located somewhere in a landfill. You don't need to add CO2 unless you have a sealed room. Would the benefits be worth the effort? I dont mind doing the work, if I will be able to see the benefits. It's just not worth NOT putting in the little bit of effort. May 23, 2017 · For me, yes it is worth it. The alternatives can cause more problems then they're worth. In fact the CO2 level in my 10 and 20 gallon tanks with DIY setup has the same CO2 level in the water as my 50 gallon with a pressurized system. Mine made too much pressure, broke the regulator, and made a huge mess in my room so I don't suggest it. DIY kits are viable, but it requires higher maintenance and you may not get the ppm of CO2 that you want. I personally like my aquarium plants more than anything for me fish are the addition rather than the plants. It will help your plants use up whatever nutrients are available, and therefore will help reduce algae. I recently dabbled into inject CO2 and decided to buy a high quality CO2 system. Dec 12, 2024 · Wondering if you need CO2 for your planted aquarium? This article explores the role of CO2 in promoting vibrant aquatic plant growth and its benefits, like improved water quality and reduced algae. I've used one of the Fluval 88 systems. DIY CO2 worth it to establish growth before adding fauna? : r/PlantedTank Scan this QR code to download the app now     TOPICS Gaming Sports Business Crypto Television Celebrity POPULAR POSTS Copy link Go to PlantedTank r/PlantedTank r/PlantedTank CO2 Diffuser: I initially tried making my own CO2 diffuser using various DIY methods, but honestly, it wasn't worth the hassle. Jul 24, 2024 · The system outputs CO2 , water vapour and heat. Is the citric acid and baking soda method worth it? Is buying a DIY co2 kit worth it? I'm looking at setting up a kit like in this video but I'm wondering if anyone has had any luck with a cheap DIY setup? I want to get my plants growing stronger, but I've heard mixed feelings on if its worth it just to save up for a decent kit or not. My box is 25. Jul 19, 2018 · I would encourage you to at least try the DIY CO2 method first because it is far less expensive (in the short term) which is just enough time to see if you enjoy having it in your tank. 00-$70. Yes stuff grows better but does that mean its more work to tame it or is it just overall more lush and healthy? Is it worth the investment?! Dec 27, 2023 · To add CO2 to your grow tent, you can use CO2 generators, CO2 tanks, fermentation, or decomposition. Thus, I was thinking of doing a DIY until such time I can afford it. I use diy co2 in my small tanks it works great and is allot cheaper. I've been running DIY CO2 since I've setup my tank. Good luck! Regards, Charlie Mims. Discover essential factors to consider, methods for CO2 injection (pressurized vs. A week ago I got a CO2 reading of 66ppm!. Hi there, I plan on adding some co2 to my aquarium to really make it flourish and would love to find a kit which isn't to expensive ( looking for plastic bottle screw on's) also would need to include all of the parts necessary besides ingredients. Aug 24, 2005 · Here the system will cost me 1/4 of my salary. 5 gallon future planted shrimp and betta tank. The DIY setup works good but depletes too rapidly if you have a large heavily planted tank. Looking to get into co2 but I can't budget pressurised co2 it into my tank. In this video I give a complete review of the DIY CO2 system that I set up 35 days ago in my nano Iwagumi inspired tank. Yes, you can make a homemade CO2 generator for your grow tent using various methods and steps. Long story short, its totally worth it. I ended up going with pressurized co2. They (broad leaf chain swords in particular) went from barely growing to outgrowing my tank. It has very inconsistent pressure so you're always adjusting the needle valve and mixing up new batches. the investment in a hot CO2 burner is more upfront but it is cheaper to run as propane gas is much cheaper than CO2 cylinders. The most important benefit to 310K subscribers in the PlantedTank community. IMO CO2 is something you should do right or don't bother. Feb 6, 2015 · My question though is Is it worth it? I was planning on building one out of a 1gal and 20oz. :rolleyes: Notice I went out and bought a CO2 meter, so I cannot claim great diy success. Jul 21, 2009 · ^^^Agreed. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced I have 5 gallon carboy a from home brewing, so I was going to run a tube from the carboy right split it off and hang it over my plants with an air stone to disperse the Co2 better. However, I have seen several beautiful tanks with no CO2. It is definitely worth setting up. Although there are the newer 2L metal co2 generator setups that seem to be better quality, so that may be an option. They are less expensive but increase heat and humidity. CO2 generators use burn propane or natural gas to produce CO2. If the growth after adding Co2 isnt all that noticeable, I cant see adding it. Are they worth it in 2020 : r/Aquariums Scan this QR code to download the app now Home Popular TOPICS Gaming Sports Business Crypto Television Celebrity RESOURCES Copy link Go to Aquariums r/Aquariums r/Aquariums Oct 17, 2023 · Unlock potential with CO2 for grow tents! Learn how CO2 contributes to photosynthesis, methods to introduce CO2, and optimizing for maximize plant growth. Behold, my DIY CO2 reactor tanks. 5"h/22"d/20"w. May 28, 2020 · Hello, so I have used the basic sugar+yeast method with nano tanks and have never had any problems whatsoever and have achieved good results always. I saw a cheap CO2 devices for $60. They work perfectly well and if you really look at it, the hassle of it breaks down into 5 minutes a week of work. Though for a 63 gallon you will need a lot more than a single 2 litre bottle, id recommend at least 4. Is a diy co2 maker worth it? Today we will be showing you how to make a diy co2 maker for plants and unboxing the Vivosun air quality detector and putting it Nov 29, 2022 · I’d advise you to go for the cheapest way to add CO2 to grow tent to maximize your yields while limiting your spending. Either go low tech and use no CO2 or go high-tech and invest in pressurized CO2, but I would strongly recommend against getting into DIY CO2. What Does CO₂ Do for Plants? CO₂ (carbon dioxide) is a critical ingredient in photosynthesis. DIY works, but it's inconsistent, doesn't last long, really only works well on smaller tanks, and can be messy. Just wondering if DIY co2 system is worth the effort? I mean it's not the hardest thing to make, but with the fluctuating co2 levels it produces is it still Yes, any co2 is better than none, and diy co2 actually works quite well. Jul 5, 2014 · It does indeed work. . Jul 18, 2025 · Is CO2 worth it in a grow room? Understanding the behavior of plants can greatly benefit your grow. It's very time-consuming. In general I see new growers concerned with things like CO2 , which only provides nominal benefits. I also Currently, I am unable to part with the cash necessary for a Co2 injection system. Jun 16, 2009 · Here is another very recent thread where someone lost almost all fish probably because of an DIY CO2 accident. jc vy 2azch7 98xzi lamb eyjnu ekeurevr wrml htkzv b2ws